We Asked “Which Tudor GMT: Black Bay Pro or Pelagos FXD?” And You Voted. Who Won?

This past weekend, we ran a poll on our instagram (@teddybaldassarre) asking which of these two Tudor GMTs you prefer: the 39mm Black Bay Pro in steel, outfitted with the COSC-certified manufacture Caliber MT5652 or the bigger, 43mm Pelagos FXD GMT in titanium, which can track three time zones and is outfitted with the COSC- and METAS-certified manufacture Caliber MT5652-U. They each have their own relative pros and cons, but the results were decisive enough to name a winner — though it was close enough to say each watch held its own.

The Black Bay Pro came out on top, with 54% of the vote, while the Pelagos FXD GMT came in with a solid 46%. A lot of comments noted that the decision came down to size and thickness, while there were at least four or five respondents who own and love both.

Stay tuned for our next poll and make sure to let us know if you’ve got a good question that you want the community to weigh in on!